White Cheddar Cheese Nuggets

Battered crispy white cheddar cheese curds with a side of ranch

$7.95

Buffalo Cauliflower

Fried cauliflower florets tossed in buffalo sauce with choice of ranch or bleu cheese

$8.95

Loaded Chili Cheese Tots

A basket of piping hot tots drenched in our house-made chili, covered with queso, shredded cheddar and drizzled with sour cream

$8.45

Buffalo Chicken Dip

Shredded chicken breast blended with cream cheese and buffalo sauce served with freshly fried tortilla chips

$7.95

Spinach Dip

Herbed cream cheese and spinach topped with parmesan with tortilla chips

$8.95

The Prodigy Nachos

House fried tortilla chips topped with beef brisket, queso blanco, pico de gallo, jalapeños, sour cream and guacamole

$12.45

Dynamite Shrimp

Beer Battered deep-fried shrimp coated in our delicious bang bang sauce served over a bed of Asian slaw

$12.95

Pretzel Fries

Warm pretzel fries topped with everything seasoning alongside honey mustard dipping sauce and house-made queso

$8.95

Fried Green Tomatoes

Buttermilk marinated deep-fried green tomato slices with a spicy ranch dipping sauce

$7.95

Prodigy Loaded Fries

Fresh fries topped with slow-roasted BBQ pork, smoked gouda, queso, and drizzled with sour cream

$8.95

In-A-Pickle

Named after our favorite childhood game Crispy beer-battered pickle spears with spicy dill ranch

$7.95

Jumbo Wings

Traditional wings tossed in the sauce or seasoning of your choice served with celery sticks and your choice of dressing

(8) $12.95

(16) $16.95

Boneless Wings

Breaded to order boneless chicken accompanied by celery sticks and your choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing

(8) $12.95

(16) $16.95

Sauce Selection:

Classic Buffalo

Parmesan Garlic

Teriyaki

Hot Honey

Sweet Chili

Carolina Reaper

BBQ

Dry Rub Selection:

Lemon Pepper

Fry Dust

Smokehouse Rub

Louisiana Rub

Sriracha Rub

Nashville Hot

Prodigy Buffalo Chicken

Crispy fried buffalo chicken tenders served on a bed of blended lettuce with tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, and your dressing selection

$13.45

Sub with buffalo cauliflower for an amazing vegetarian option

TY Cobb

Romaine lettuce mix topped with grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumber, and red onion with your choice of dressing

$13.45

Traditional Caesar

Chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing topped with croutons and parmesan cheese

$8.95

Chicken $4

Shrimp $9

Salmon $9

Seasonal Salad

Fresh mixed greens drizzled with balsamic reduction, candied pecans, sliced strawberries, goat cheese, craisins, and apple slices served with apple vinaigrette

$9.45

Chicken $4

Shrimp $9

Salmon $9

The Wedge

Classic wedge salad dressed with creamy bleu cheese topped with bacon, bleu cheese, and tomato

$8.95

Chicken $4

Shrimp $9

Salmon $9

Shrimp Salad

Mixed field greens topped with sautéed shrimp, avocado, tomato, red onion, and cucumber with sesame ginger vinaigrette

$16.95

Dressing Selections:

Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Apple Vinaigrette, Spicy Dill Ranch, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Sesame Ginger Vinaigrette

Classic

Two slices of American cheese, Prodigy sauce

$12.45

Pulled Pork & Gouda

Bacon, pulled pork, smoked gouda & BBQ sauce on our signature bun

$13.95

Bacon & Bleu

Bacon, a handful of fries, bleu cheese crumbles & buffalo sauce

$13.95

The Mac & Cheese

American cheese, house made mac & cheese & bacon dressed with garlic aioli

$13.95

Mushroom & Swiss

Two slices of swiss cheese & caramelized mushrooms on our signature house bun smeared with truffle mayo

$12.45

Quadruple Bypass

Four thinly smashed patties topped with American cheese, bacon, Prodigy sauce & queso on a pretzel bun with white cheddar cheese nuggets

$19.95

Pineapple & Pepper Jack

Teriyaki, pepper jack cheese & grilled pineapple on our signature bun

$12.45

Philly

Swiss cheese, queso, caramelized onions, mushrooms & garlic aioli on a pretzel bun

$12.45

Prodigy Melt

American cheese, caramelized onions & Prodigy sauce sandwiched between two slices of Texas toast

$12.45

Chili & Pepper Jack

Pepper jack cheese, our house-made chili, drizzled with sriracha ranch

$12.45

Reaper

Pepper jack cheese, jalapeños, fried onions, dressed with Carolina reaper sauce

$12.45

Bacon & Cheddar

Four slices of bacon, cheddar cheese, Prodigy sauce, on a sesame seed bun

$17.95

The No Name Burger

Thick-cut bacon, goat cheese, caramelized onion, balsamic glaze & truffle mayo on a sesame bun

$17.95

Black & Bleu

Bleu cheese mousse, onion straws & horseradish cream sauce on a sesame bun

$17.45

Fried Egg & Bacon

Our award winning burger: fried egg, thick-cut bacon & queso

$17.45

Peanut Butter Burger

Peanut butter, bacon, jalapeños & sharp cheddar cheese on a sesame bun

$17.45

Bun

Signature house bun

Sesame bun

Lettuce

Pretzel Bun $1

Gluten Free Bun $2

No Bun

Protein

Two Smash Patties $9

Two Bison Smash Patties $15

Two Wagyu Smashed Patties $12

Salmon Filet $14

Signature Blended Patty $13

Grilled Chicken Breast $10

Turkey $10

Beyond Burger (plant-based) $12

One Smash Patty $5

More Protein

Fried Egg $1

Beef Brisket $3

Chili $1

Extra Beef Patty $5

Pulled Pork $2

Bacon $1

Mac & Cheese $2

Cheese

American $1

Pepper Jack $1

Bleu Cheese $1

Gouda $1

Goat Cheese $2

Cheddar $1

Swiss $1

Parmesan $1

Melted Queso $1

Pimento Cheese $1

Toppers

Lettuce

Tomato

Cole Slaw $0.50

Avocado $1

Sautéed Mushrooms $1

Onion Straws $0.50

Strawberry Slices $1

Pickle

Onion

Guacamole $1

Pico De Gallo $1

Sautéed Onions $1

Peanut Butter $0.50

Grilled Pineapple $1

Fresh Sliced Jalapeño $0.50

Sauces

Garlic Aioli $0.50

Barbecue $0.50

Prodigy Sauce $0.50

Teriyaki Glaze $0.50

Carolina Reaper Sauce $0.50

Bang Bang Sauce $0.50

Spicy Ranch $0.50

Buffalo Sauce $0.50

Truffle Mayo $0.50

*The Hoosier Daddy

An Indiana favorite, hand-breaded deep-fried pork tenderloin topped with dill pickle chips on brioche bun

$13.95

*BLT with a Twist

A heap of bacon, lettuce, and tomato topped with garlic aioli between two slices of Texas toast

$12.95

*Nashville Hot

Nashville hot chicken with dill pickle chips & pimento cheese served on our signature house bun

$13.95

*CLT

Fried green tomatoes, lettuce & pimento cheese on Texas toast Add Bacon for $2

$12.95

Add Bacon $4

*Grilled BBQ Chicken

BBQ grilled chicken breast, bacon, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing

$13.95

Add buffalo sauce if you like it a bit spicy

*Beef & Cheddar

Smoked beef brisket topped with cheddar cheese & horseradish cream sauce on our signature bun

$13.95

*Prodigy BBQ

Slow roasted pulled pork drizzled with sweet BBQ sauce, onion straws & pickle chips on our pretzel bun

$13.95

Chicken Tenders Basket

Beer battered chicken tenders with a dipping sauce of your choice, served with fries

$13.95

The Big Catch

Two beer-battered cod filets topped with house made cole slaw on a sesame seed bun served with fries

$13.95

Fish & Chips

Hand-dipped Beer battered cod with salt & vinegar fries, coleslaw and tartar sauce garnished with lemon wedges

2 Pieces $13.95

3 Pieces $16.95

Fried Shrimp Platter

Crispy shrimp served with french fries, a side coleslaw, and choice of tartar or cocktail sauce

$16.95

Teriyaki Salmon

Grilled teriyaki glazed salmon served with steamed broccoli and Asian slaw

$14.95

Beef Brisket Mac & Cheese

Our house-made mac & cheese topped with smoked gouda, beef brisket, sautéed onions, and mushrooms dressed with fried onion straws, served with a side of Texas Toast

$13.95

Buffalo Mac & Cheese

Our signature mac & cheese mixed with buffalo chicken dip, two fried chicken tenders topped with bleu cheese with Texas toast

$13.95

Pimento Mac & Cheese

Our signature mac & cheese blended with pimento cheese topped with a fried green tomato

$13.95

Add BBQ pulled pork $2

*Our burgers and eggs are cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. *We offer products that may contain peanuts, tree nuts, soy, milk, eggs, and wheat. While we take steps to minimize the risk of cross-contamination, we cannot guarantee any of our products are safe to consume for people with peanut, tree nut, soy, milk, egg, or wheat allergies.

Windy City Dog

The traditional Chicago style dog a Nueske hot dog topped with tomato, relish, pickle, sport pepper, mustard, celery salt on a poppy seed bun

$12.95

The Western Dog

This will be the one that is always on your mind. Nueske hot dog on a poppy seed bun with Prodigy pulled pork, dressed in BBQ sauce, and topped with coleslaw, and freshly fried onion straws

$12.95

Southern Indiana Dog

Prodigy chili, queso, minced onions, shredded cheddar over a Nueske dog on a poppy seed bun

$12.95

The German Dog

A hot dog topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Prodigy Sauce

$12.95

Could Be Cancun

Our hot dog topped with queso, fresh pico de gallo, guacamole, caramelized onions, and fresh sliced jalapeños

$12.95

Thick Cut Fries with house blend fry dust $3

Salt & Vinegar Fries $3

Sweet Potato Fries $4

Truffle Fries $4

Tater Tots $4

Pub Chips $2.50

Onion Rings $4

Cup of Chili $3

Cole Slaw $3

Steamed Broccoli $4

Side House Salad $5

Side Caesar Salad $5

Fresh Cut Fruit $4

Signature Mac & Cheese $4

Grilled Cheese

American cheese sandwiched between two slices of Texas Toast

$5

Kids Smash Burger

A thinly smashed patty topped with American cheese and a side

$5

Cheese Curd Basket

Our crispy cheese curds served with french fries and ranch dipping sauce

$5

Grilled Hotdog

A grilled hot dog on a poppy seed bun with a side selection

$5

Mac & Cheese

House-made mac & cheese

$5

Grilled Chicken & Broccoli

Grilled chicken alongside steamed broccoli

$5

Chicken tenders

Our crispy tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce

$5

Fish & Chips

One portion of deep-fried cod served with french fries and a wedge of lemon

$5

Brownie Bites

House Baked Otis Spunkmeyer Cookie

Handcrafted Ice Cream Sandwich

Milkshakes for All

Classic Vanilla $5.95

Chocolate Madness $5.95

Strawberry Sweetness $5.95

Cookies & Cream $5.95

Gooey Caramel $5.95

Kids Milk Shake $3.95

For Those Over 21

Dine-in Only

PBB Mudslide $10

Maple Bacon Royale $10

Milks-ology 102 $10

Drunken Nut $10

Cinnamon Toast Crunch $10

Brownie Ala Mode

Rich chocolate brownie alongside a scoop of vanilla ice cream drizzled with chocolate syrup and topped with whipped cream & a cherry

$5.95

Turtle Brownie Ala Mode

Rich chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream drizzled with caramel syrup topped with candied pecans, whipped cream & a cherry

$6.45

Classic Root Beer Float

IBC Root Beer poured over a scoop of vanilla ice cream

$5.95

Cookies & Milk

4 House baked Otis Spunkmeyer chocolate chip cookies and milk

$4.95

Cinnamon Pretzel Sticks

Warm pretzel fries tossed in cinnamon sugar served with caramel dipping sauce

$8.95