White Cheddar Cheese Curds

Battered, crispy white cheddar cheese curds with a side of ranch

$7.95

Brussels Sprouts

Fried Brussels sprouts tossed in sweet chili, garnished with bacon and cilantro

$7.95

Tex-Mex Rolls

Deep-fried, el pastor-seasoned chicken, with onions, pineapple, pepperjack cheese and cilantro, served with sweet BBQ sauce

$10.95

Buffalo Chicken Dip

Shredded chicken breast blended with cream cheese and buffalo sauce, served with house-fried tortilla chips

$8.45

Dip Trio

Queso, guacamole and spinach dip, served with house-fried tortilla chips

$10.95

Prodigy Nachos

House-fried tortilla chips, topped with beef brisket, queso blanco, pico de gallo, jalapeños, sour cream and guacamole

$12.95

Dynamite Shrimp

Beer battered, deep-fried shrimp, coated in our delicious dynamite sauce served over a bed of Asian slaw

$12.95

Pretzel Twists

Three salted pretzel twists, served with your choice of house-made queso or honey mustard dipping sauce

$8.95

Fried Green Tomatoes

Buttermilk marinated, deep-fried green tomato slices, with a ranch dipping sauce

$7.95

Prodigy Loaded Fries

Fresh fries topped with slow-roasted BBQ pork, smoked gouda, queso, and drizzled with sour cream

$8.95

In-A-Pickle

Named after our favorite childhood game. Crispy, beer-battered pickle spears with ranch

$8.45

Prodigy Buffalo Chicken

Crispy fried buffalo chicken tenders, served on a bed of romaine lettuce with tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles and your dressing selection

$13.95

Sub Brussels sprouts for a vegetarian option

Ty Cobb

Romaine, topped with grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumber, red onions and your choice of dressing

$13.95

Traditional Caesar

Chopped romaine, tossed with Caesar dressing, croutons and shredded parmesan

$7.95

Chicken $7

Shrimp $7

Salmon $7

Seasonal Salad

Peaches, strawberries, oranges, pineapple, and blueberries on a bed of freshly mixed greens, with dressing of your choice

$9.45

Chicken $7

Shrimp $7

Salmon $7

Caprese Salad

Arugula, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, olive oil, balsamic glaze drizzle and freshly chopped basil

$8.95

Chicken $7

Shrimp $7

Salmon $7

Salmon Salad

Grilled salmon, on a bed of arugula topped with peaches, oranges, freshly shredded beets, and goat cheese served with sesame ginger dressing

$14.95

Dressing Selections:

Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Apple Vinaigrette, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Sesame Ginger Vinaigrette, House-Made Green Goddess, Prodigy Sauce

Classic

American cheese and Prodigy sauce on a house bun

$9.95

Cuban

Smash patty with ham, pulled pork, Swiss cheese and pickles, topped with mustard aioli

$11.95

Bacon & Bleu

Bacon, seasoned fries, bleu cheese mousse & buffalo sauce

$11.95

Mac & Cheese

American cheese, bacon, garlic aioli, topped with signature mac and cheese

$11.95

Mushroom & Swiss

Swiss cheese and sautéed mushrooms, on our signature house bun, topped with truffle mayo

$10.45

Quadruple Bypass

Four smash patties, topped with American cheese, bacon, Prodigy sauce & queso on a pretzel bun with white cheddar cheese nuggets (no upgrades)

$19.95

Pineapple & Pepperjack

Teriyaki, pepperjack cheese & pineapple salsa on our signature bun

$10.45

Philly

Swiss cheese, queso, sautéed onions, mushrooms & garlic aioli on a pretzel bun

$10.45

Prodigy Melt

Two smash patties, American cheese, caramelized onions and Prodigy sauce, between two slices of Texas toast

$13.45

Jamaican Black Bean

Jerk-seasoned, black bean burger, pineapple salsa, pepperjack cheese, all on a house bun

$11.95

Donut

Toasted Italian donut bun, fresh mozzarella, peanut butter, fresh jalapeño slices and strawberry jam

$11.95

Bacon & Cheddar

Four slices of bacon, cheddar cheese, Prodigy sauce, on a sesame seed bun

$17.95

The No Name Burger

Thick-cut bacon, goat cheese, caramelized onion, balsamic glaze & truffle mayo on a sesame bun

$17.95

Caprese

Topped with fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, balsamic reduction drizzle, and finished with chopped basil

$17.45

Fried Egg & Bacon

Our award winning burger: fried egg, thick-cut bacon, tater tots, queso

$16.95

Bun

Signature house bun

Sesame bun

Lettuce

Pretzel Bun $2

Gluten Free Bun $2

No Bun

Protein

Double Smash Patties $12

Two Wagyu Smashed Patties $14

Salmon Filet $14

Signature Beef Blend $13

Grilled Chicken Breast $10

Black Bean Burger $10

Beyond Burger (plant-based) $12

One Smash Patty $9

More Protein

Fried or Boiled Egg $1

Beef Brisket $3

Chili $1

Pulled Pork $2

Bacon $2

Ham $2

Cheese

American $1

Pepperjack $1

Bleu Cheese Mousse $1

Gouda $1

Goat Cheese $2

Cheddar $1

Swiss $1

Parmesan $1

Melted Queso $1

Fresh-Sliced Mozzarella $2

Toppers

Lettuce

Tomato

Cole Slaw $0.50

Avocado $0.50

Sautéed Mushrooms $1

Onion Straws $1

Strawberry Slices $1

Pickle

Onion

Guacamole $2

Pico De Gallo $1

Sautéed Onions $1

Peanut Butter $0.50

Pineapple Salsa $1

Fresh Sliced Jalapeño $0.50

Arugula $0.50

Mac & Cheese $2

Sauces

Garlic Aioli $0.50

Barbecue $0.50

Prodigy Sauce $0.50

Teriyaki Glaze $0.50

Dynamite Sauce $0.50

Ranch $0.50

Buffalo Sauce $0.50

Truffle Mayo $1

Balsamic Reduction $0.50

Mustard Aioli $0.50

The Hoosier Daddy*

An Indiana favorite. Hand-breaded, deep-fried pork tenderloin topped with dill pickle chips on house bun

$13.95

BLT with a Twist*

A heap of bacon, lettuce, and tomato topped with garlic aioli between two slices of Texas toast

$12.95

Prodigy BBQ*

Slow-roasted pulled pork with sweet BBQ sauce, onion straws and pickle chips on a pretzel bun

$13.45

Add buffalo sauce if you like it a bit spicy

Hot Ham and Cheese

Sliced ham, Prodigy sauce, American and cheddar cheese on Texas toast

$12.95

Grilled Jerk Chicken

A jerk-seasoned grilled chicken breast with pineapple salsa on a signature bun

$13.95

Fish & Chips

Beer-battered fish with salt & vinegar fries, coleslaw and side of tartar sauce, garnished with lemon wedges

2 Pieces $13.95

3 Pieces $16.95

Teriyaki Salmon

Grilled, teriyaki-glazed salmon, over a bed of Asian slaw, alongside fresh, steamed broccoli

$14.95

Beef Brisket Mac & Cheese

Our signature mac & cheese, tossed with sautéed mushrooms and onions, topped with beef brisket, smoked gouda and fried onions straws, served with a slice of Texas toast

$13.95

Buffalo Mac & Cheese

Our signature mac and cheese, mixed with buffalo chicken dip, topped with bleu cheese crumbles and two hand-dipped buffalo chicken tenders served with a slice of Texas toast

$13.95

Spinach Mac & Cheese

Our signature mac and cheese, blended with house-made spinach dip and sautéed mushrooms, topped with pico de gallo, crumbled goat cheese and grated parmesan, served with a slice of Texas toast

$12.95

Buffalo Chicken

Hand-bread, deep-fried chicken breast, drenched in buffalo sauce, with ranch and bleu cheese mousse on a signature bun

$13.45

Chicken Tenders Basket

Beer-battered chicken tenders, served with fries and dipping sauce of your choice

$13.95

*Our burgers and eggs are cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. *We offer products that may contain peanuts, tree nuts, soy, milk, eggs, and wheat. While we take steps to minimize the risk of cross-contamination, we cannot guarantee any of our products are safe to consume for people with peanut, tree nut, soy, milk, egg, or wheat allergies.

Windy City Dog

Nathan's Famous all beef hot dog, topped with tomato, relish, pickle, chopped onions, mustard and celery salt on a poppy seed bun

$8.95

Southern Indiana Dog

Prodigy chili, queso, minced onions and shredded cheddar over a Nathan's Famous all beef hot dog on a poppy seed bun

$8.95

Fries with House Blend Fry Dust $3

Salt & Vinegar Fries $3

Sweet Potato Fries $4

Truffle Fries $4

Tater Tots $4

Pub Chips $2.50

Onion Rings $4

Cup of Chili $3

Cole Slaw $3

Steamed Broccoli $4

Side House Salad $4

Side Caesar Salad $4

Fresh Cut Fruit $4

Signature Mac & Cheese $4

Grilled Cheese

American cheese sandwiched between two slices of Texas Toast

$5

Kids Smash Burger

A thinly smashed patty topped with American cheese

$5

Cheese Curds

Our crispy cheese curds

$5

Mac & Cheese

House-made mac & cheese

$5

Grilled Chicken & Broccoli

Grilled chicken alongside steamed broccoli

$5

Chicken tenders

Our crispy tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce

$5

Fish & Chips

One portion of deep-fried cod served with french fries and a wedge of lemon

$5

Brownie Bites

Grandma's Chocolate Chip Cookie

Milkshakes for All

Classic Vanilla $5.95

Chocolate Madness $5.95

Strawberry Sweetness $5.95

Cookies & Cream $5.95

Gooey Caramel $5.95

Kids Milk Shake $3.95

For Those Over 21

Dine-in Only

PBB Mudslide $9.95

Orange Dream $9.95

Drunken Nut $9.95

Very Berry Delight $9.95

Cinnamon Toast Crunch $9.95

Creamy Coffee Midnight $9.95

Turtle Brownie Ala Mode

Rich chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream drizzled with caramel syrup topped with candied pecans, whipped cream & a cherry

$5.95

Classic Root Beer Float

IBC Root Beer poured over a scoop of vanilla ice cream

$5.95

Strawberry Shortcake

A crisp chocolate chip waffle, vanilla ice cream, strawberry compote, topped with whipped cream and a cherry

$5.95

Chocolate Peanut Butter Donut

A cinnamon sugar deep-fried donut, perched on a dollop of peanut butter, drizzled with chocolate syrup, strawberry jam, and a scoop of chocolate ice cream and fresh strawberries

$5.95