Before Burgers
-
White Cheddar Cheese Nuggets
Battered crispy white cheddar cheese curds with a side of ranch
$7.95
-
Buffalo Cauliflower
Fried cauliflower florets tossed in buffalo sauce with choice of ranch or bleu cheese
$8.95
-
Loaded Chili Cheese Tots
A basket of piping hot tots drenched in our house-made chili, covered with queso, shredded cheddar and drizzled with sour cream
$8.45
-
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Shredded chicken breast blended with cream cheese and buffalo sauce served with freshly fried tortilla chips
$7.95
-
Spinach Dip
Herbed cream cheese and spinach topped with parmesan with tortilla chips
$8.95
-
The Prodigy Nachos
House fried tortilla chips topped with beef brisket, queso blanco, pico de gallo, jalapeños, sour cream and guacamole
$12.45
-
Dynamite Shrimp
Beer Battered deep-fried shrimp coated in our delicious bang bang sauce served over a bed of Asian slaw
$12.95
-
Pretzel Fries
Warm pretzel fries topped with everything seasoning alongside honey mustard dipping sauce and house-made queso
$8.95
-
Fried Green Tomatoes
Buttermilk marinated deep-fried green tomato slices with a spicy ranch dipping sauce
$7.95
-
Prodigy Loaded Fries
Fresh fries topped with slow-roasted BBQ pork, smoked gouda, queso, and drizzled with sour cream
$8.95
-
In-A-Pickle
Named after our favorite childhood game Crispy beer-battered pickle spears with spicy dill ranch
$7.95
-
Jumbo Wings
Traditional wings tossed in the sauce or seasoning of your choice served with celery sticks and your choice of dressing
(8) $12.95
(16) $16.95
-
Boneless Wings
Breaded to order boneless chicken accompanied by celery sticks and your choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing
(8) $12.95
(16) $16.95
-
Sauce Selection:
Classic Buffalo
Parmesan Garlic
Teriyaki
Hot Honey
Sweet Chili
Carolina Reaper
BBQ
-
Dry Rub Selection:
Lemon Pepper
Fry Dust
Smokehouse Rub
Louisiana Rub
Sriracha Rub
Nashville Hot
Have It as Greens or Make It a Wrap
Wraps are served on sun-dried tomato tortillas with house-fried pub chips-
Prodigy Buffalo Chicken
Crispy fried buffalo chicken tenders served on a bed of blended lettuce with tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, and your dressing selection
$13.45
Sub with buffalo cauliflower for an amazing vegetarian option
-
TY Cobb
Romaine lettuce mix topped with grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumber, and red onion with your choice of dressing
$13.45
-
Traditional Caesar
Chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing topped with croutons and parmesan cheese
$8.95
Chicken $4
Shrimp $9
Salmon $9
-
Seasonal Salad
Fresh mixed greens drizzled with balsamic reduction, candied pecans, sliced strawberries, goat cheese, craisins, and apple slices served with apple vinaigrette
$9.45
Chicken $4
Shrimp $9
Salmon $9
-
The Wedge
Classic wedge salad dressed with creamy bleu cheese topped with bacon, bleu cheese, and tomato
$8.95
Chicken $4
Shrimp $9
Salmon $9
-
Shrimp Salad
Mixed field greens topped with sautéed shrimp, avocado, tomato, red onion, and cucumber with sesame ginger vinaigrette
$16.95
-
Dressing Selections:
Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Apple Vinaigrette, Spicy Dill Ranch, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Sesame Ginger Vinaigrette
Smash Burgers
All smash burgers are not created equal, you choose from beef, bison, wagyu, or even sub for a Beyond burger. All of our patties are fully cooked and paired with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle and served with fries. | Upgrade from beef: wagyu $2.00, bison $5.00, Beyond $2.00-
Classic
Two slices of American cheese, Prodigy sauce
$12.45
-
Pulled Pork & Gouda
Bacon, pulled pork, smoked gouda & BBQ sauce on our signature bun
$13.95
-
Bacon & Bleu
Bacon, a handful of fries, bleu cheese crumbles & buffalo sauce
$13.95
-
The Mac & Cheese
American cheese, house made mac & cheese & bacon dressed with garlic aioli
$13.95
-
Mushroom & Swiss
Two slices of swiss cheese & caramelized mushrooms on our signature house bun smeared with truffle mayo
$12.45
-
Quadruple Bypass
Four thinly smashed patties topped with American cheese, bacon, Prodigy sauce & queso on a pretzel bun with white cheddar cheese nuggets
$19.95
-
Pineapple & Pepper Jack
Teriyaki, pepper jack cheese & grilled pineapple on our signature bun
$12.45
-
Philly
Swiss cheese, queso, caramelized onions, mushrooms & garlic aioli on a pretzel bun
$12.45
-
Prodigy Melt
American cheese, caramelized onions & Prodigy sauce sandwiched between two slices of Texas toast
$12.45
-
Chili & Pepper Jack
Pepper jack cheese, our house-made chili, drizzled with sriracha ranch
$12.45
-
Reaper
Pepper jack cheese, jalapeños, fried onions, dressed with Carolina reaper sauce
$12.45
Signature Burgers
Signature beef blend sourced exclusively for Prodigy Burger Bar. Cooked to your favorite temperature, paired with your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle. Served with fries.-
Bacon & Cheddar
Four slices of bacon, cheddar cheese, Prodigy sauce, on a sesame seed bun
$17.95
-
The No Name Burger
Thick-cut bacon, goat cheese, caramelized onion, balsamic glaze & truffle mayo on a sesame bun
$17.95
-
Black & Bleu
Bleu cheese mousse, onion straws & horseradish cream sauce on a sesame bun
$17.45
-
Fried Egg & Bacon
Our award winning burger: fried egg, thick-cut bacon & queso
$17.45
-
Peanut Butter Burger
Peanut butter, bacon, jalapeños & sharp cheddar cheese on a sesame bun
$17.45
Create Your Own Masterpiece
Served with fries-
Bun
Signature house bun
Sesame bun
Lettuce
Pretzel Bun $1
Gluten Free Bun $2
No Bun
-
Protein
Two Smash Patties $9
Two Bison Smash Patties $15
Two Wagyu Smashed Patties $12
Salmon Filet $14
Signature Blended Patty $13
Grilled Chicken Breast $10
Turkey $10
Beyond Burger (plant-based) $12
One Smash Patty $5
-
More Protein
Fried Egg $1
Beef Brisket $3
Chili $1
Extra Beef Patty $5
Pulled Pork $2
Bacon $1
Mac & Cheese $2
-
Cheese
American $1
Pepper Jack $1
Bleu Cheese $1
Gouda $1
Goat Cheese $2
Cheddar $1
Swiss $1
Parmesan $1
Melted Queso $1
Pimento Cheese $1
-
Toppers
Lettuce
Tomato
Cole Slaw $0.50
Avocado $1
Sautéed Mushrooms $1
Onion Straws $0.50
Strawberry Slices $1
Pickle
Onion
Guacamole $1
Pico De Gallo $1
Sautéed Onions $1
Peanut Butter $0.50
Grilled Pineapple $1
Fresh Sliced Jalapeño $0.50
-
Sauces
Garlic Aioli $0.50
Barbecue $0.50
Prodigy Sauce $0.50
Teriyaki Glaze $0.50
Carolina Reaper Sauce $0.50
Bang Bang Sauce $0.50
Spicy Ranch $0.50
Buffalo Sauce $0.50
Truffle Mayo $0.50
Not Burgers
*Served with house-made pub chips-
*The Hoosier Daddy
An Indiana favorite, hand-breaded deep-fried pork tenderloin topped with dill pickle chips on brioche bun
$13.95
-
*BLT with a Twist
A heap of bacon, lettuce, and tomato topped with garlic aioli between two slices of Texas toast
$12.95
-
*Nashville Hot
Nashville hot chicken with dill pickle chips & pimento cheese served on our signature house bun
$13.95
-
*CLT
Fried green tomatoes, lettuce & pimento cheese on Texas toast Add Bacon for $2
$12.95
Add Bacon $4
-
*Grilled BBQ Chicken
BBQ grilled chicken breast, bacon, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing
$13.95
Add buffalo sauce if you like it a bit spicy
-
*Beef & Cheddar
Smoked beef brisket topped with cheddar cheese & horseradish cream sauce on our signature bun
$13.95
-
*Prodigy BBQ
Slow roasted pulled pork drizzled with sweet BBQ sauce, onion straws & pickle chips on our pretzel bun
$13.95
-
Chicken Tenders Basket
Beer battered chicken tenders with a dipping sauce of your choice, served with fries
$13.95
-
The Big Catch
Two beer-battered cod filets topped with house made cole slaw on a sesame seed bun served with fries
$13.95
-
Fish & Chips
Hand-dipped Beer battered cod with salt & vinegar fries, coleslaw and tartar sauce garnished with lemon wedges
2 Pieces $13.95
3 Pieces $16.95
-
Fried Shrimp Platter
Crispy shrimp served with french fries, a side coleslaw, and choice of tartar or cocktail sauce
$16.95
-
Teriyaki Salmon
Grilled teriyaki glazed salmon served with steamed broccoli and Asian slaw
$14.95
-
Beef Brisket Mac & Cheese
Our house-made mac & cheese topped with smoked gouda, beef brisket, sautéed onions, and mushrooms dressed with fried onion straws, served with a side of Texas Toast
$13.95
-
Buffalo Mac & Cheese
Our signature mac & cheese mixed with buffalo chicken dip, two fried chicken tenders topped with bleu cheese with Texas toast
$13.95
-
Pimento Mac & Cheese
Our signature mac & cheese blended with pimento cheese topped with a fried green tomato
$13.95
Add BBQ pulled pork $2
-
*Our burgers and eggs are cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. *We offer products that may contain peanuts, tree nuts, soy, milk, eggs, and wheat. While we take steps to minimize the risk of cross-contamination, we cannot guarantee any of our products are safe to consume for people with peanut, tree nut, soy, milk, egg, or wheat allergies.
Crowd Pleasers
All hot dogs are served with fries-
Windy City Dog
The traditional Chicago style dog a Nueske hot dog topped with tomato, relish, pickle, sport pepper, mustard, celery salt on a poppy seed bun
$12.95
-
The Western Dog
This will be the one that is always on your mind. Nueske hot dog on a poppy seed bun with Prodigy pulled pork, dressed in BBQ sauce, and topped with coleslaw, and freshly fried onion straws
$12.95
-
Southern Indiana Dog
Prodigy chili, queso, minced onions, shredded cheddar over a Nueske dog on a poppy seed bun
$12.95
-
The German Dog
A hot dog topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Prodigy Sauce
$12.95
-
Could Be Cancun
Our hot dog topped with queso, fresh pico de gallo, guacamole, caramelized onions, and fresh sliced jalapeños
$12.95
Next to Burgers
-
Thick Cut Fries with house blend fry dust $3
Salt & Vinegar Fries $3
Sweet Potato Fries $4
Truffle Fries $4
Tater Tots $4
Pub Chips $2.50
Onion Rings $4
Cup of Chili $3
Cole Slaw $3
Steamed Broccoli $4
Side House Salad $5
Side Caesar Salad $5
Fresh Cut Fruit $4
Signature Mac & Cheese $4
Kids Corner
Designed for those 12 and under, all meals include beverage, fries or a fruit cup and choice of dessert-
Grilled Cheese
American cheese sandwiched between two slices of Texas Toast
$5
-
Kids Smash Burger
A thinly smashed patty topped with American cheese and a side
$5
-
Cheese Curd Basket
Our crispy cheese curds served with french fries and ranch dipping sauce
$5
-
Grilled Hotdog
A grilled hot dog on a poppy seed bun with a side selection
$5
-
Mac & Cheese
House-made mac & cheese
$5
-
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli
Grilled chicken alongside steamed broccoli
$5
-
Chicken tenders
Our crispy tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce
$5
-
Fish & Chips
One portion of deep-fried cod served with french fries and a wedge of lemon
$5
-
Brownie Bites
House Baked Otis Spunkmeyer Cookie
Handcrafted Ice Cream Sandwich
Don't Forget Milkshakes & Dessert
-
Milkshakes for All
Classic Vanilla $5.95
Chocolate Madness $5.95
Strawberry Sweetness $5.95
Cookies & Cream $5.95
Gooey Caramel $5.95
Kids Milk Shake $3.95
-
For Those Over 21
Dine-in Only
PBB Mudslide $10
Maple Bacon Royale $10
Milks-ology 102 $10
Drunken Nut $10
Cinnamon Toast Crunch $10
-
Brownie Ala Mode
Rich chocolate brownie alongside a scoop of vanilla ice cream drizzled with chocolate syrup and topped with whipped cream & a cherry
$5.95
-
Turtle Brownie Ala Mode
Rich chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream drizzled with caramel syrup topped with candied pecans, whipped cream & a cherry
$6.45
-
Classic Root Beer Float
IBC Root Beer poured over a scoop of vanilla ice cream
$5.95
-
Cookies & Milk
4 House baked Otis Spunkmeyer chocolate chip cookies and milk
$4.95
-
Cinnamon Pretzel Sticks
Warm pretzel fries tossed in cinnamon sugar served with caramel dipping sauce
$8.95