Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

food on a table next to a cup of coffee

The Prelude

  • In-A-Pickle

    Crispy beer-battered pickles spears served with your choice of adobo sauce or spicy dill ranch. Named after our favorite childhood game

    $8

  • Cheese Curds

    Crispy cheese curds served with a side of your choice of adobo sauce or ranch

    $9

  • Loaded Chili Cheese Tots

    A basket of tots drenched in our house-made chili, queso, mozzarella, and a drizzle of sour cream on top

    $8

  • Hemingway's Bang Bang Shrimp

    Fried beer-battered shrimp coated in our delicious bang bang sauce, drizzled with sriracha, and served over a garnish of Asian slaw

    $13

  • Buffalo Chicken Dip

    Our secret recipe with shredded chicken. Served with house-made potato chips. You won't be disappointed

    $9

  • Sliders

    3 sliders served with your choice of blackened chicken with Pepper Jack cheese or Prodigy's Signature Beef Blend topped with cheddar cheese

    Chicken $12

    Beef $20

    Add fries for $4

  • Street Tacos

    Taco Night on Tuesday | Served on corn tortillas, topped with queso fresco, and house-made pico de gallo and an adobo sauce drizzle

    3 each

    Pulled pork or chicken $10

    Shrimp or pulled filet tips $12

  • Thomas Edison Stuffed Breadsticks

    Pepperoni & mozzarella stuffed breadsticks served with marinara, white queso & parmesan cheese

Sandwiches

Served with fries unless otherwise notated

  • The Hoosier Daddy (Tenderloin Night on Monday)

    What else? An Indiana tenderloin breaded and served with Indiana's Own Batch #2 Stone Ground Mustard (Who is your favorite Hoosier?)

    $14

  • Iron Mike's Beyond Burger

    The Beyond Burger patty slathered with grilled onions, mushrooms, and provolone cheese. Served on a brioche bun with steamed broccoli on the side

    $14

    Substitute gluten-free bun for + $2

  • The Prodigy PBBQ

    Our in-house slow-roasted pulled pork with Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce. Topped with onion straws, pickles, served on a pretzel bun

    $13

  • The Turducken

    Named affectionately for the G.O.A.T. football announcer, this turkey burger is topped with Asian slaw, Pepper Jack cheese, avocado, and Indiana's Own Batch #2 Stone Ground Mustard. Served with duck fat pomme frites and garnished with a signature prodigy BBQ chicken wing on top

    $14

  • Reggie's BLT

    A heap of bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle topped with garlic aioli and sandwiched between two slices of Texas toast. Served with pub chips

    $12

  • The Stu Ungar

    This math won multiple poker, gin & chess tournaments in his lifetime. We top a grilled chicken breast with Pepper Jack cheese, roasted red pepper, tomato, avocado, tortilla strips & chipotle mayonnaise

    $14

  • The Bird

    Named after legendary native-born 3 point shooter. Crispy fried chicken, pickles, and adobo sauce on a brioche bun served with fries

    $13

  • The Buffalo Bird

    He is so awesome, we used his name twice. Buffalo-tossed crispy fried chicken topped with bleu cheese crumbles. Served on a brioche bun with fries

    $14

  • "The Momoa" Hawaiian

    Atlantic salmon covered with teriyaki glaze, Asian slaw mix, and grilled pineapple atop a brioche bun. Served with a side of broccoli

    $16

  • The Jimmy Buffet Catch

    Inspired by the beach themed tunes of this musical legend. Two beer-battered cod fillets with tartar sauce and Asian slaw mix on a sesame seed bun. Served with pub chips

    $22

The Hoagies

A 6-inch hoagie topped with all the fixings. Served with pub chips

  • The Desi: Our Cubano

    Our cubano with house-made pulled pork, ham, Swiss cheese, and Indiana's Own Batch #2 Stone Ground Mustard

    $15

  • The Fresh Prince

    A hoagie roll filled with shredded fillet tips, grilled onions, green peppers, provolone cheese, and queso

    $14

  • The Bubba Gump Po Boy

    Our favorite way to eat our shrimp, what's yours? Crispy beer-battered shrimp, coated in bang-bang sauce and Asian slaw

    $15

More Than Just Burgers

The Others: Skillet Plates

  • Fajitas

    Served with red & green peppers, caramelized onions, guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream, cilantro-lime rice, and corn tortillas

    Chicken $14

    Filet tip $15

    Shrimp $16

  • Smothered Chicken

    Prodigy's take on a fan favorite. Grilled chicken topped with sautéed onions, red and green peppers, mushrooms, and provolone cheese. Served with choice of broccoli or green beans as side

    $16

  • Smothered Shredded Filet Tips

    Our house slaw, roasted filet tips sautéed with onions, greens & red peppers, mushrooms, and smothered in provolone cheese. Served with choice of broccoli or green beans as side

    $16

The Not-So-Usual Suspects

  • Chicken Tenders Basket

    Crispy-friend chicken tenders served with coleslaw, French fries, and honey mustard

    $15

  • The Ahab

    A whale-sized portion of beer-battered cod served with French fries, coleslaw & housemade tartar sauce

    $17

  • Fried Shrimp Platter

    Crispy, seasoned shrimp served with French fries and coleslaw. Your choice of tartar sauce or cocktail sauce on the side

    $17

  • Teriyaki Salmon

    Grilled salmon filet topped with a housemade teriyaki glaze. Served with mashed potatoes and green beans

    $20

  • Sautée Shrimp Pasta

    Cavatappi pasta topped with sautéed shrimp, broccoli, cherry tomatoes, garlic butter, and parmesan. Served with Texas toast

    $26

  • Bruce Lee's Kung Pao Chicken

    Marinated chicken breast chunks, broccoli, red & green peppers stir-fried in a sweet & spicy sauce over a bed of cilantro-lime rice. Garnished with peanuts and sesame seeds. Skip the chicken for a delicious vegetarian option

    $14

  • Filet Tip Mach & Cheese

    Our mouth-watering mac and cheese topped with filet tops and parmesan served with Texas Toast

    $20

  • Sautée Shrimp and Veggie Platter

    12 shrimp sautéed with olive oil, fresh diced garlic, broccoli, red and green peppers, and carrots. Served with side salad with choice of dressing

    $20

    Keto-friendly

Wings

½ Wing Wednesdays

  • Choice of Fresh Never Frozen Jumbo Wings or Breaded to Order Boneless Chicken | All wings are served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery

  • Traditional Wings

    8 $11

    16 $18

  • Traditional Wings Combo Basket

    Baskets include coleslaw and fries or side of choice (additional charges may apply)

    8 $15

    16 $24

  • Sauces

    Sweet BBQ

    Parmesan Garlic

    Teriyaki

    Sweet Chili

    Classic Buffalo

  • Dry Rub

    Lemon Pepper

    Fry Dust

    Smokehouse Rub

    Louisiana Rub

    Sriracha Rub

The Nachos

  • The Prodigy Nachos

    House-made potato chips topped with shredded filet tips, white queso, jalapeños, pico de gallo, sour cream & guacamole

    $13

  • The Express Nachos

    Can you name this famous Pitcher? Tortilla chips topped with nacho cheese sauce, our in-house slow-roasted pulled pork with BBQ and sour cream drizzle

    $13

That's A Wrap!

All wraps served with side of house pub chips. Sub fries or another side for additional charge

  • Pulled Pork

    Our slow-roasted pulled pork served with Asian slaw, BBQ sauce, and onion straws wrapped in a jalapeño cheddar tortilla

    $12

  • Chicken Caesar

    Grilled chicken breast topped with caesar salad dressing, romaine lettuce mix, and shaved parmesan cheese. Wrapped in a spinach tortilla

    $11

  • Thai Chili Shrimp

    Sautéed shrimp tossed in sweet chili sauce with Asian slaw and green & red peppers on a spinach tortilla wrap

    $14

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Hand-battered crispy fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce topped with crumbled bleu cheese, shredded mozzarella, lettuce, and tomato. Served on a jalapeño cheddar tortilla

    $12

  • All The Veggie

    Roasted red & green peppers, onions, mushrooms, Pepper Jack cheese, orange dill sauce & Asian slaw in a spinach tortilla

    $10

  • Steak and Cheese

    Philly would be proud... pulled filet tips, house-made queso, red & green peppers wrapped in a jalapeño tortilla

    $12

Greens

Greens with Protein

  • Prodigy Buffalo Chicken

    Crispy-fried buffalo chicken tenders served on a bed of lettuce with cherry tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, shredded mozzarella cheese, and your choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing

    $12

  • TY Cobb

    Romaine lettuce mix topped with a hard-boiled egg, shredded mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, sliced ham, crumbled bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumber, and onions

    $15

  • Chicken Caesar

    Chopped romaine & iceberg lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing topped with grilled chicken, croutons, and parmesan cheese

    $10

  • Innovator

    Stacked salad with kale, apples, cranberries, pecans, grilled chicken tossed in our house-made apple vinaigrette. Can you name the innovative genius whose favorite food was kale?

    $15

    Add bleu cheese crumbles for $2

  • Shrimp Salad

    Artisan greens, shrimp, avocado, tomato, cucumber & red onions, served with house-made spicy dill ranch dressing

    $14

    Substitute salmon for $2

  • House-Made Dressing Choices:

    Ranch

    Bleu Cheese

    Apple Vinaigrette

    Spicy Dill Ranch

    1000 Island

    Caesar

    Honey Mustard

Just The Greens

Add Chicken - 4 | Add Shrimp - 5 | Add Salmon - 6

  • Berry Spring

    Mixed greens, walnuts, mixed berries, apple slices, cherry tomatoes tossed in an apple vinaigrette dressing

    $12

  • 7 Iron

    Put away your wedge and club up to our applewood smoked bacon, crumbled bleu cheese, hard-boiled egg, tomato & our house-made bleu cheese dressing

    $9

  • Kale for Keto

    A bed of kale served with a hard-boiled egg, crumbled bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, avocado, with dill ranch on the side

    $12

    Keto-friendly

Smash Burgers

All burgers are fully cooked, paired with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles by request, and served with fries

  • America's Smash Burger

    Two thinly-smashed patties served with two slices of American cheese, Prodigy sauce, lettuce, onions, tomato, and pickle. Served on a brioche bun with a side of fries

    $12

  • Burt Reynold's Smash Burger

    We mustache you a question? A double-decker burger filled with two thinly-smashed patties, shredded filet tips, fontina cheese, sliced avocado, and adobo sauce. Served on a brioche bun

    $14

  • The Duke

    Name this famous cowboy. Our cowboy burger topped with two thinly-smashed patties, bacon, pulled pork, cheddar cheese, and BBQ sauce on a brioche bun

    $13

  • The Metallica

    A burger to rock your taste buds. Our classic double Smash burger topped with bacon, a handful of fries, bleu cheese crumbles, and buffalo sauce atop a brioche bun

    $13

  • Mushroom and Swiss

    Sautéed mushrooms, two slices of Swiss cheese, and truffle mayo round out this classic smash

    $12

  • Macafee

    Tell us your cheesiest joke. Two thinly-smashed patties covered in mac and cheese, bacon, and garlic aioli. Served on a brioche bun

    $14

  • The Betty Melt

    Two thinly-smashed patties, caramelized onions, special sauce, and American cheese sandwiched between two slices of Texas toast. We couldn't think of a famous Patty, so Betty White wins again

    $12

  • Fire and Ice

    Prodigy's Signature Beef Blend topped with fontina cheese and sriracha, all on a brioche bun

    $12

  • Quadruple Bypass

    Make sure you're cleared by the doctor to take on this 4-patty burger... Four thinly-smashed patties topped with cheese curds, American cheese, bacon, Prodigy sauce, and queso on top. Served on a pretzel bun

    $19

The Wannabe G.O.A.T

  • Build Your Own Burger

    See served for build your own card

  • Bun

    Pretzel $1

    Gluten free $2

    Brioche

    Sesame

    Lettuce bun

    No bun

  • Protein

    Price includes side of fries

    2 thinly pressed smash patties $9

    Signature Beef Blend patty $11

    Fresh bison burger $14

    Wagyu beef burger $15

    House-made turkey patty $10

    Grilled chicken $11

    Beyond burger (plant-based) $13

    Atlantic salmon filet $14

  • Extra Protein

    Fried Egg $1

    Ham $1

    Pulled pork $1

    Bacon $1

    Chili $1

    Shredded filet tips $1

    Mac & cheese $1

    Extra patty $2

  • Cheese

    American $1

    White American $1

    Provolone $1

    Swiss $1

    Cheddar $1

    Shredded mozzarella $1

    Pepper Jack $1

    Melted queso $1

    Shaved parmesan $1

    Bleu cheese crumbles $2

    Creamy fontina $1

  • Sauced Up

    Garlic aioli $0.50

    Barbecue $0.50

    Prodigy sauce $0.50

    Zesty orange dill $0.50

    Stone Ground Mustard $0.50

    Bang bang sauce $0.50

    Zesty dill ranch $0.50

    House-made adobo $1

    Prodigy bourbon glaze $1.50

    Truffle mayo $1

    Teriyaki glaze $1

  • Temp

    All beef and bison burgers are cooked to order. Other proteins come full cooked

    Rare

    Medium rare

    Medium

    Medium well

    Well done

  • Toppers

    Lettuce

    Pickle

    Mayo

    Yellow mustard

    Tomato

    Onion

    Red peppers $0.50

    Green peppers $0.50

    Fresh sliced jalapeños $0.50

    Coleslaw $0.50

    Peanut butter $0.50

    Strawberry slices $0.50

    Grilled pineapple $0.50

    Tortilla strips $0.50

    Onion straws $0.50

    Sautéed mushrooms $1

    Sautéed onions $1

    Guacamole $1

    Avocado $1

    Pico de gallo $1

The Spuds

  • Thick-Cut Fries

    House-made secret seasoning

  • Tater Tots

  • Sweet Potato Fries

  • Truffle Fries

  • Duck Fat Pomme Frites

  • Loaded Bacon Fries

  • Chili Cheese Tater Tots

The Sides

  • Coleslaw

  • Fresh-Cut Fruit

  • Steamed Broccoli

  • Green Beans

  • Signature Mac and Cheese

  • Mashed Potatoes

  • Side Salad

    Caesar

Burgers

Our fresh never frozen, hand-selected signature beef blend, sourced exclusively for Prodigy. All burgers are cooked to your favorite temp, paired with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle by request, and served with fries.

  • The G.O.A.T.

    Yes, he is the G.O.A.T. unless you were born after 2005. He loved his bacon cheeseburgers so much that one fast food place near the stadium started carrying bacon to put on his cheeseburgers after games. A single signature blended patty topped with Prodigy sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles & onion on a sesame seed bun with 4 slices of smoked bacon

    $15

  • The Mozart

    Prodigy's Signature Beef Blend topped with crumbled bleu cheese, fried onion straws & zesty orange dill sauce. A symphony for your taste buds

    $14

  • The Sheriff

    Two Greats from Tennessee. Prodigy's Signature Beef Blend topped with Swiss & cheddar cheese and Jack Daniel's whiskey glaze

    $14

  • The Crasian

    Prodigy's Signature Beef Blend topped with peanut butter, bacon, jalapeños, and sharp cheddar cheese

    $14

  • The Nacho Mama

    Prodigy's Signature Beef Blend topped with all of the accouterments from our Prodigy Nachos

    $14

Bison Burgers

Our fresh never frozen bison, lean in fat, but bold in flavor. All bison burgers are cooked to your favorite temp, paired with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles by request, and served with fries

  • The Black Sabbath

    Pioneering heavy metal, this burger has an inspired kick. A seasoned bison patty topped with Pepper Jack cheese, our house-made chili, drizzled with sriracha ranch. Served on a brioche bun

    $14

  • The Buffalo Bill

    A fresh bison burger topped with a fried egg, cheddar, and avocado served on a lettuce wrap with a side of broccoli

    $15

    Keto-friendly

  • The Ted Turner

    Paying homage to the predecessor of our first location. Fresh bison topped with house pulled pork, Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, and fried onion strings

    $16

Wagyu Burgers

The best of the best, translating to Japanese Cow and known for its amazing flavor. All wagyu burgers are cooked to your favorite temp, paired with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle by request, and served with fries

  • The Prodigy

    Topped with Pepper Jack and cheddar cheeses, mushrooms, caramelized onions & red & green peppers with garlic aioli. Our fajita burger

    $17

  • The 16th Masterpiece

    Leonardo DaVinci is credited to 15 masterpieces. We would imagine this would be his 16th. Topped with 16 mushrooms, Swiss cheese, and fontina cheese

    $17

  • The 21 Burger

    A wagyu burger topped with filet tips, white American cheese, shredded mozzarella, and truffle mayo. Served over sautéed onions on a brioche bun

    $18

  • The Gordon Bleu

    A seasoned wagyu patty topped with sliced ham, Swiss cheese, and zesty dill sauce. Served on a sesame seed bun

    $17

  • The People's Champion

    Our award-winning burger from the 292.5 Morning Showdown Burger Contest, topped with bacon, egg, and queso cheese

    $16

  • The Captain

    Named after one of our founders, topped with applewood smoked bacon, white American cheese, and truffle mayo

    $17

*Our store offers products with peanuts, tree nuts, soy, milk, eggs and wheat. While we take steps to minimize the risk of cross-contamination, we cannot guarantee that any of our products are safe to consumer for people with peanut, tree nut, soy, milk, egg or wheat allergies. 

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Especially if you have certain medical conditions.

  • a tray of food on a table
    Slide 1 of 10
  • a close up of food on a table
    Slide 2 of 10
  • food on a table next to a cup of coffee
    Slide 3 of 10
  • a tray of food on a table
    Slide 4 of 10
  • a sandwich sitting on top of a picnic table
    Slide 5 of 10
  • a sandwich sitting on top of a plate of food
    Slide 6 of 10
  • a sandwich sitting on top of a wooden table
    Slide 7 of 10
  • a sandwich sitting on top of a table
    Slide 8 of 10
  • a sandwich sitting on top of a table
    Slide 9 of 10
  • a close up of food on a table
    Slide 10 of 10

    • All Age Shakes

    • Cookies and Cream

      $6

    • Chocolate Madness

      $6

    • Sweet Strawberry

      $6

    • Gooey Caramel

      $6

    • Classic Vanilla

      $7

    • Root Beer Float

      $7

    Adult Milkshakes

    • Maple Bacon Royale

      $10

    • Milks-Ology 102

      $10

    • Deep Sweet South

      $10

    • Jail House Rock

      $10

    • Cinnamon Toast Crunch

      $10

    Desserts

    • Jim Brownie

      Rich brownie served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle

      $7

    • Red Velvet Cake

      Topped with whipped cream and strawberry slices

      $7

    The Damon Bailey

    KIDS UNDER 11
    Price includes soda and choice of tater tots or fruit cup

    • Grilled Ham and Cheese

      Ham and American cheese sandwiched on one sliced Texas toast

      $7

    • Kids Smash Burger

      Thinly-smashed patty topped with American cheese

      $7

    • Cheese Curd Basket

      Our crispy cheese curds

      $7

    • Mac and Cheese

      Cavatappi pasta slathered in our delicious queso

      $7

    • Grilled Chicken And Broccoli

      Chopped grilled chicken tossed in broccoli

      $7

    • Kids Chicken Tenders

      Crispy-fried chicken tenders with your choice of sauce

      $7

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!